The Magnitude of the Indian Elephants in the Battles of Raphia (Polybius V 84.5-6) and Magnesia (Livy XXXVII 39.13). Where is the Mistake?

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3989/emerita.2020.01.1940

Keywords:

Indian elephants, African elephants, μέγεθος, magnitudo, privative opposition

Abstract


Until Africa was colonised, there was a general consensus that the Indian elephants of Antiochus III, which defeated Ptolemy IV’s Libyan ones in the battle of Raphia (217 B.C.) as described by Polybius, were far greater in size. Livy confirms this in his account of the battle of Magnesia (190 B.C.). Despite this, the use of the word μέγεθος suggests a different meaning than magnitude, and so Polybius did not make a mistake, as suspected, after all. Whilst the Roman historian refers to the great individual size of each species of elephant, the Greek is referring to the scale of the elephantry itself. The key to this interpretation lies in the double value of the unmarked term in the privative opposition between μέγεθος and πλῆθος, magnitudo and multitudo. The first two terms represent, in addition to individual size specifically, the generic concept of magnitude.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bailly, A. 2000: Dictionnaire grec français, París, Hachette.

Balasch Recort, M. 1981: Polibio. Historias, libros V-XV. Introducción, traducción y notas, Madrid, Gredos.

Berrey, M. 2017: Hellenistic Science at Court, Berlín y Boston, W. de Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110541939

Brandt, A. L. et al. 2014: «The Elephants of Gash-Barka, Eritrea: Nuclear and Mitochondrial Genetic Patterns», Journal of Heredity 105:1, pp. 82-90. https://doi.org/10.1093/jhered/est078 PMid:24285829

Casson, L. 1993: «Ptolemy II and the Hunting of African Elephants», Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association 123, pp. 247-260. https://doi.org/10.2307/284331

Casson, L. 1993: «A Petrie Papyrus and the Battle of Raphia», Bulletin of the American Society of Papyrologists 30, pp. 87-92.

Charles, M. B. 2007: «Elephants at Raphia. Reinterpreting Polybius 5.84-85», Classical Quartertly 57, pp. 306-311. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009838807000341

Charles, M. B. 2008: «African Forest Elephants and Turrets in the Ancient World», Phoenix 62, pp. 338-362.

Charles, M. B. 2016: «Elephant Size in Antiquity: DNA Evidence and the Battle of Raphia», Historia 65:1, pp. 53-65.

Cobb, M. 2016: «The Decline of Ptolemaic Elephant Hunting: Analysis of the Contributory Factors», Greece and Rome 63, pp. 192-204. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0017383516000061

Foucault, J. A. de 1972: Recherches sur la langue et le style de Polybe, París, Les Belles Lettres.

García-Hernández, B. 2005: «La estructura de oposición privativa y la dialéctica de Hegel», en Calboli, G. (ed.), Papers on Grammar IX 1-2. Proceedings of the Twelfth International Colloquium on Latin Linguistics, Roma, Herder, vol. I, pp. 245-255. https://doi.org/10.1515/joll.2005.9.1.245

García-Hernández, B., en prensa: «La evolución significativa de los correlativos tantus y tam magnus y su continuidad en español», en Penas Ibáñez, A. (ed.), Sémantique de la locution, de la phrase, de l'énoncé / Semántica de la frase, de la oración y del enunciado, Bulletin Hispanique 123.

Gowers, W. 1948: «African Elephants and Ancient Authors», African Affairs 47, pp. 173-180. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.afraf.a093647

Grubb P. et al. 2000: «Living African Elephants Belong to Two Species: Loxodonta africana (Blumenbach, 1797) and Loxodonta cyclotis (Matschie, 1900)», Elephant, 2:4, pp. 1-4. https://doi.org/10.22237/elephant/1521732169

Liddell, H. G. y Scott, R. 1996: A Greek-English Lexikon, Óxford, Clarendon Press.

Löfstedt, E. 1911: Philologischer Kommentar zur Peregrinatio Aetheriae, Upsala, Almqvist y Wiksell.

Mauersberger, A. et al. 2006: Polybios-Lexikon. Berlín, Akademie Verlag.

OGIS: Wilhelm Dittenberger 1903: Orientis Graeci inscriptiones selectae, vol. prius, Leipzig, Hirzel.

Paton, W. R. 1954: Polybius. The Histories, vol. III. Cambridge Mass., Harvard University Press.

Pédech, P. 1977: Polybe. Histoires, livre V. Texte établi et traduit, París, Les Belles Lettres.

Reinach, S. 1881: «Elephas», en Daremberg, C. y Saglio, E., Dictionnaire des antiquités grecques et romaines, París, Hachette, s. v., pp. 536-544.

Roca, A. L. et al. 2005: «Cytonuclear Genomic Dissociation in African Elephant Species», Nature Genetics 37:1, pp. 96-100. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng1485 PMid:15592471

Sancho Royo, A. 2008: Polibio, Historias, libros V-VI. Texto revisado y traducido con introducción y notas, Madrid, CSIC y Tirant lo Blanch.

Schneider, P. 2009: «De l'Hydaspe à Raphia: rois, éléphants et propagande d'Alexandre le Grand à Ptolémée IV», Chronique d'Égypte 84, pp. 310-334. https://doi.org/10.1484/J.CDE.3.15

Scullard, H. H. 1995: The Elephant in the Greek and Roman world, Cambridge, Thames and Hudson.

Taboada Hernán, G. H. 1995: «Polibio (5.84.5 s.) y los elefantes de Rafia», Habis 26, pp. 113-117.

Tarn, W. W. 1926: «Polybius and a Literary Commonplace», Classical Quaterly 20, pp. 98-100. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009838800050345

TLL 1900 ss.: Thesaurus linguae latinae, Leipzig, Teubner / Berlín, De Gruyter.

Toynbee, J. M. C. 1982: Animals in Roman Life and Art, Ithaca NY, Cornell University Press.

Walbank, F. W. 1957: A Historical Commentary on Polybius, vol I, Óxford, Clarendon Press.

Weil, R. 1982: Polybe. Histoires, livres VII-VIII et IX. Texte établi et traduit, París, Les Belles Lettres.

Downloads

Published

2020-06-30

How to Cite

García-Hernández, B. (2020). The Magnitude of the Indian Elephants in the Battles of Raphia (Polybius V 84.5-6) and Magnesia (Livy XXXVII 39.13). Where is the Mistake?. Emerita, 88(1), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.3989/emerita.2020.01.1940

Issue

Section

Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)